PUTTING THE HEALTH BACK IN HEALTHCARE
Medicine Redefined
Medicine Redefined
Dr. Darsh Shah, DO & Dr. Altamash Raja, DO interview practitioners who challenge the norm and promote health during a time when the healthcare system feels broken. Find out how experts in the fields of sleep, nutrition, exercise, stress resilience, rehabilitation, precision & performance medicine, and so many more are using "unconventional" approaches to move the needle forward and redefine medicine as we know it.
Oct. 5, 2026

211. Strength vs. Hypertrophy: Load, Weekly Sets, Training to Failure, and the Minimum Effective Dose (Training Series, Part 2)

211. Strength vs. Hypertrophy: Load, Weekly Sets, Training to Failure, and the Minimum Effective Dose (Training Series, Part 2)
Medicine Redefined
211. Strength vs. Hypertrophy: Load, Weekly Sets, Training to Failure, and the Minimum Effective Dose (Training Series, Part 2)

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

How many hard sets does muscle actually need, and does the weight on the bar matter? In part two of the training series, Dr. Altamash Raja and Dr. Darsh Shah work through the 2026 ACSM position stand: strength and size as two goals with two prescriptions, why effort matters more than load for growth, and how little it takes to maintain what you've built. They audit their own programs live, then make the case for building a training floor around your real constraints before adding anything.

TOPICS COVERED

  • Strength vs. hypertrophy: two goals, two prescriptions, and why you need to know which one you're chasing
  • What the 2026 ACSM position stand asks for: heavy loads for strength, at least 10 hard sets per muscle per week for size, effort over load
  • Progressive overload, momentary failure vs. 2–3 reps in reserve, and correcting the "80% = RPE 8" slip from part one
  • A live audit of both hosts' programs with fractional set counting, plus the Nordic hamstring evidence debate
  • The maintenance dose: keeping strength and size on as little as one session a week, and what older adults need
  • Allostatic load, rest intervals, full-body vs. split training, and why you build the floor first, then add

RESOURCES & LINKS MENTIONED

Studies

Concepts & tools

On-air corrections

  • Allostatic load was coined by McEwen and Stellar in 1993, not the 1930s or 40s.
  • In Zhang 2026, the lowest mortality was in people combining resistance training with aerobic activity. These are observational cohort data.

FOLLOW US

The Show

Dr. Altamash Raja

Dr. Darsh Shah

Want a clear plan for longevity, performance, and staying active with fewer setbacks? Work with Dr. Raja directly. Book at refininghealthrx.com (https://refininghealthrx.com).

0:00 Welcome to Medicine Redefined. I'm Dr. Altamash Raja. And I'm Dr. Darsha. Let's put the health back in healthcare. If you're a high performer who wants a clear plan for longevity, performance, and staying active with fewer setbacks, and you want to work with me directly, you can book at refininghealthrx.com. All right, let's jump in. All right, Dr. Altamash Raja, welcome back, man. It's good to be back. Thank you. Yeah. Hasn't been too long, at least, I guess, from our first discussion on this topic and the overview that we are doing in regards to setting up and how to build a holistic strength conditioning exercise program for our listeners.

0:44 And this has been a highly requested topic, it seems like, just throughout the years, but then you've gotten some suggestions. So what are we going to get into today? Okay. So on the docket today is to build a comprehensive program targeting strength and hypertrophy. And I think maybe a good place to start is creating a distinction for most people. I guess maybe just to get a lay of the land, what is your understanding? How would you explain to the layperson the differences between strength and hypertrophy? Maybe to it. Okay. Yeah. I mean, I think me personally, if to a layperson, I would say strength, I'm looking more at a number. So like strength, I'm looking at how much are you lifting?

1:26 How are we increasing the weight of whatever it might be, right? That's our metric I would say we're looking at. Whereas hypertrophy, we're looking at more muscle mass and maybe aesthetics. And again, correlated to weight, but that's not necessarily the metric that we would use. Because now you're looking at other variables like repetitions, time under tension, etc. Whereas strength, we're looking more at the central nervous adaptation. I love it. Yeah, it's interesting that when you look at it that way, because it's almost you're looking at different strategies to attain the goal. I think you're definitely hitting on some of the key components of it. And the interesting thing is that getting stronger and bigger, they're certainly related, but the evidence when we look at that, actually, this is fun to do is actually go back and learn some things on this as well.

2:10 But when we're looking at just the evidence to come at this, it's treating them as two different goals with And if you don't know which one you're after, you can't really tell whether or not programs working. I think we had talked about on the overview episode is you have to have the objective. It's like, where are we trying to go? And then how do we measure against that? Because if you're trying to see if something's successful, we do this in medicine, right? We're looking at the A1C, we're looking at certain markers. Well, the same thing. I think I recently talked about this on social media is when the proxies become the goal, that becomes a problem, right? So what is our goal when we're trying to go for one of these variables and how are we going to measure that? And so- I think maybe I highlighted the ACSM paper and just because it was so comprehensive, I'll come back to that.

2:52 The American College of Sports Medicine paper from earlier this year led by a courier, right? So in it, they talked about this. For strength, the prescription was pretty much instilling heavier loads, at least 80% of your one repetition maximum, right? So I think I talked about that one max, basically how much can you lift for one rep? Absolutely. momentary failure. I don't want to say mechanical failure. I say momentary failure. And what you're trying to do is 80% of that two to three sets, at least two sessions a week, going through full range of motion. That is like the bare bones prescription per that paper that we had referenced earlier. And the key lifts you want to do early in the session for exactly the reason you mentioned, right? Central nervous system fatigue is going to be a problem when you're trying to develop force.

3:35 And so you want to do that while you're fresh. For size, it's a little bit different. The driver here is weekly volume. And this is something that's been discussed a lot on social media. Mike has talked a lot about this from Renaissance Prioritization. People might have heard about this magical number of 10 sets per muscle group per week. You've heard that, right? Yeah. Yes. A lot of people talk about somewhere in the 10 to 20 range. And so they touched on this as well. And that's what the data is really pointing to is for muscle growth, you want to try to hit the minimum threshold 10. Again, there are some nuances to that, which we'll talk about in my program. And it's quite hitting that for certain reasons. But what's interesting is the load matters a lot less than we think here. So anywhere from 30% of your one RM to 100% of your max produce similar growth when we equate total weekly volume, right?

4:23 So you can do lightweight up to 30 reps, anywhere between five reps and 30 reps. It's going to be. Now, the key point is, though, we have to be able to hit close to momentary failure, right? So you're really pushing the intensity no matter how many reps you're doing or whatever load that is. So it really doesn't matter whether you're at 50% or high repetitions or whatever it is. A long time ago, I think that in programming, maybe even as recently as 8 to 10 years ago, we used to think that anything beyond 12 reps, anything beyond 15 reps was more muscular endurance. Turns out that's not the case. If you're getting closer to that one RIR, two RIRs that we talked about, you're still going to be getting some of those hypertrophy gains. So one thing I want to correct from last episode that I didn't go back and listen to that is that I did mention that at one point, 80% is like eight RPE.

5:11 And that's not the same thing because it's conflating different things. 80% of your max is going to be the absolute load, which for most people might be anywhere from five to eight or nine reps, depending on how hard you can push it. And eight RPE is like the perceived exertion like you highlighted. Is that novel information to you or is this something that you're familiar with? Anything in that? Anything in that? No, I think at least for me, obviously, being into this type of stuff and wanting to be more scientific when it comes to me, I think this is knowledge that I've seen. I think the part about muscular endurance, I still see that stuff pop up on Instagram, even from reputable sources, people, influencers, still talking about how higher reps and they kind of show that spectrum, right?

5:51 But their endurance, so hypertrophy to strain. So you typically see that chart. Yeah. But when you say volume, could you just do the easy calculation of multiplying the weight times the reps and that will give you how much weight you're doing? Is that what you mean by volume? That's a great question. So now, yeah, so what you're talking about is like how much weight times the reps you're doing. Yeah, that's one way to look at it. I think the volume what we're talking about is how many sets you're doing, right? And also how many reps you're actually getting in. And so when you equate for that, it doesn't really seem to matter, like what's the load of your pushing, because you're still getting that. So you had talked about different drivers of muscle growth, right? So you talk mechanical tension is one of them.

6:32 What are some of the other ones? So metabolic stress is another one. So mechanical tension would be to actually pushing really close to that one RM 90%. Metabolic stress would be where blood flow restriction training and things like that comes in. Time under tension would also put things like metabolic stress, I think. There are one or two that I'm actually not thinking of right now. Do a quick search for me in terms of the drivers of muscle growth real quick. See what comes up. Mechanic, intentional, metabolic stress. What about like concentric, eccentric portions? Like how much you're spending in each time? Yeah, that would be time under tension. I think that would fall under metabolic stress. And metabolic stress can come in different varieties, right? You could do tempo training. You could do high repetitions.

7:12 You could do occlusion training, which would be what blood flow restriction would be. I think maybe those are the two main ones, right? Yeah, I think let's say here. Progressive overload is in there, but that's... Yeah, these are weird. I mean, when I type this in, it's giving me like the physiological drivers, like muscle damage. But exactly what you're saying, to get to those, it's talking about training volume, proximity to failure, prioritized tension, metabolic stress. So, yeah, mechanical transduction, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Those are the main things that you're looking at to drive muscle growth. And again, I wanted to make this point again, when I was looking at the literature to talk about this, I think when people think failure, one, be careful not to say mechanical failure, because that's suggesting that the quality of the movement is being degraded.

7:54 And momentary failure is the terminology that they had used in ACS and PIPER. So continue using that and hold each other accountable when we don't do that. Again, two reps in reserve, three probably is where you want to be if you want to have that progressive low overload over time. And again, maybe progressive overload is a concept, but... are familiar with? If they're not, would you care to elucidate what that means exactly for folks? For progressive overload? Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, it's basically whatever variable you're going to choose, whether it's increased weight or increased time under tension, whatever variable you choose, you're going to progressively make it harder week after week. Once you can essentially change you're going to have a goal, right?

8:35 So let's say your goal is 85 pound dumbbell decline press for eight reps. And you're doing, let's say seven, right? Yeah, I guess I'm talking about my, let's say you're doing seven right now. Well, you're not just going to automatically go and hit like 90s for 10, right? I mean, you're going to try to find a way where you might do 65 for a warmup, and then 80, 80, and then for that last one, do 85 and try to hit that target. But then the next week, maybe you take that number two and three set and you increase it by five pounds. And so eventually that's kind of what that progressive overload is. So there's multiple ways of doing it from your first set, your last set, to... Right. Decreasing the time of rest. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, you hit it like as you're talking about training density, right?

9:17 So the rest interval could be less. You could add one extra rep. You could add an extra half back. Again, to your point, so many different ways to do that. And you can get creative with that, but we're not going to get too far to the weeds there. I, in anticipation of this, I had asked you for your workout. So maybe what we can do is if it's still the same as it was a couple of days ago when you texted me that, we can audit our workflow to see actually where some gaps are because you'd be interested. There's little room for moving to yours. And we can talk about that because I'm curious if you... After learning about some of these principles, if you would be interested in changing it or whether this is an intentional gap that you have built in there, you're like, I'm going to make this straight off because of competition coming up in three weeks.

9:59 Yeah, about three weeks. And I'm scared as hell. Yeah. For a listener who doesn't know, Doc's going to do his higher prox with his N95 on because... And hopefully with my poop sustained, where do you have to be in my gut? Exactly. Exactly. So I thought that maybe, yeah. So why don't you give the listener a little bit of your weekly overview of what your training program looks like at this time? And then we'll do a little calculation. Yeah. So, I mean, I don't even know where to start with this, honestly, because it's been so different. And I guess the biggest overview that I can get is when I was younger, I was like an athlete. I played sports all year round. There was no true training besides like running track and sprinting and just being very athletic and just playing outdoors. As college approached, got a lot more into strength training. And I forgot a lot about that cardio.

10:41 Recently, now that I moved to Florida, weather's nice all year round. I've been trying to increase my cardio, really trying to improve zone two ever since that buzzword dropped a few years ago, increased VO2 max. And that's by playing tennis, doing some fitness classes, and then still keeping some strength exercises in there. And then doing some hybrid training. So a little bit mixed up the strength portion and the cardio together in a session. Right now, while training for high rocks, this one, it's a little bit different. It's a little bit sporadic. So I'll say my target once a week, the one work that I have to do is a high rock simulation. So that's my hybrid training. where I'll probably total run about four miles, three to four miles, and break those up into about 500 meter to maybe 1,000 meter runs, and then go ahead and do some sort of station.

11:27 So that could be like a sled push, a sled pull, squats, lunges, burpees, things like that. So what I'm really doing is training a lot of threshold, threshold training, giving my heart rate high, but then also trying to train endurance, especially like endurance, because that's what high rocks is mainly about. which for me, very difficult because I'm very twitchy. I'm a type 2A type person. I'm very explosive. So for me to train kind of this aerobic muscular endurance, wow, it is difficult for me to do 40 lunges sucks. Whereas I see people do 120 and I'm like, how the hell are you doing this? These are weighted lunges or body weight? Weighted lunges, 45 pound sandbag. Yeah. So that's primarily like that's the primary target. Now, when you break up all those components of what high rocks need.

12:08 So you need your zone two. So about once or twice a week, I'll add in like either 20 to 30 minutes or maybe a longer run or bike ride, which could be 60 minutes, also two. Then another day I might be doing tennis, which for me, it's kind of a variability again. It's really bringing my heart rate up to maybe 175, 180, bringing it back down to 120. So it's a lot of just kind of heart rate training that I'm going back and forth, but then also focusing on agility, just something I enjoy. Okay. Then another two days out of the week will be more strength training. Now, this is where it can be sporadic depending on how my back feels and how tight and sore I might be. So a lot of it's upper strength training, but now recently I'm letting go of pure strength and I'm doing more like pull-ups, training the forearms, more back. And this is because high-ross kind of demands that type of endurance from those muscles.

12:51 What else am I missing there? So tell the listener a little bit of specific strength movements that you're doing. And then we'll see because I'll see if it still adds up to what I counted. Yeah, so typically I'll be doing like incline dumbbell presses, shoulder presses, any type of rows. So that might be seated cable rows or a T-bar row, pull-ups as well. Then as far as like lower strength goes, if I am really focusing on that, I'll do belt squats, typically because I have a really bad back. But then I'm looking at quads and hamstrings too. So that could be in the form of lunges, wall balls. But if I'm doing pure strength, then I'm looking at kind of the machines that you would use, leg extension, leg curls. I don't really train calves that much. And then sometimes I'll throw in abs. But that's where I'm looking at that. But as far as volume goes, I'm probably doing maybe eight sets total per session.

13:39 strength training. Yeah, just strength training. Yeah. How many total sessions are in strength? Maybe two. One and a half to two. Just depends. Sometimes I'll throw in a kettlebell workout instead if I want to do a multi-planar and just get some aerobic exercise in. Yeah. So I did mention that last episode, you know, you could hand it to your favorite AI and have it count your weekly total sets. But I think that if we wanted to do it by hand, there was actually a paper by P. Lynn and colleagues, I think from earlier this year that actually looked at different ways. They test different ways to count your sets and liked how they had it. This is something new. Historically, what I used to do this. So you talked about dumbbell bench press, right? So people probably know this, but... A dumbbell bench press or an incline press is going to be your primarily chest movement, but then you have synergists as well.

14:22 So, you know, that's also going to be your anterior delts and it's going to be your triceps as well. So any type of compound movement that you do is going to help multiple muscles. So you can think about your primary mover for each exercise and then what's the secondary mover or helper mover. And so historically, what I used to do is I would say, okay, well, if I'm doing dumbbell, chest press or whatever, bench press, we'll call it, that is hitting three sets for my chest, three sets for triceps, three sets for inch or delts. Well, these guys actually look at it a better way. And I think this is what I'm going to start using. They said, take the primary mover, count one set towards that, and then half a set towards a secondary, right? And so in that bench press example, you would give half a set to, let's just say you're doing four sets.

15:04 You would give four sets to the chest. You'd give two sets to triceps and two sets to your delts, interior delts, right? And if you wanted a more symmetric, aesthetic bodybuilding goal that you were going for, then you kind of have that three-dimensional and look at the different heads of the deltoid, but that's beyond the purpose of this discussion here. But that's how one way you can look at it. So I think that's actually pretty interesting. That's how I'm going to start calculating moving forward. But when I did the math, I mean, look, no surprise, you're a little bit heavy on the lower body. I excluded, my initial thought was because you're doing some sprinting and stuff, that's going to register into your hamstrings. But digging deeper into the literature, When they're looking at performance, they actually tend to exclude for that, right? So when I'm looking at your pressing stuff, we're looking at three sets for chest, nine sets for back.

15:48 This is coming your pull-ups and rows. Shoulders will include a little bit of wall ball if you want to, but maybe 10 sets there. Biceps comes in with the pulling stuff. Triceps come in with the chest press. Quads, a lot of lunges you mentioned. Glutes is going to be some of the, again, lunges and squats that you're doing. but no direct hamstring stuff that you had mentioned, right? No hinging directly stuff that you're doing and stuff. So one thing in terms of gap, right? We're talking about, you're playing a lot of tennis. And so zero direct sets, Almost all your lower body is pushing variations. Maybe not a change. Probably don't want to make a lot of changes this close. But one thing that you might want to look at is adding some maybe Nordic hamstring exercises. Hamstring curls again, maybe wouldn't directly jump to that.

16:30 But this is one of the favorite things that people will talk about people who have. Goals for performance, which is who you are, my friend, because you love to play tennis and you're getting different things, is how that can cut hamstring injuries by up to 50%. This is a 2019 meta-analysis that looked at 8,500 athletes, Van Dyke and colleagues, and they reported that Nordic hamstring curls, injuries, hamstring injuries, 50%. 2021, Impellerisi colleagues re-appraised this and called the evidence inclusive, not absent. And so any thoughts to that is, is this new for you? Hamstring stuff? Do you hate doing hamstrings? Tell me more. No, I love hamstrings. So I was doing a lot of RDLs, I would say a month ago.

17:11 I did tweak my hamstring a little bit, especially like right behind the knee. And honestly, I think I was doing a seated light girl. And some, I don't know if it was the interface of the calf or the hamstring, but I took a break from it and it got better. But knowing me, I just keep pushing through things. Artie yells, man, I just, I'm like genetically just, if I do one set, I'm sore for three days just for like the hamstring portion. But it's funny because when I, because Hyroxin is so neat, it's like everything's done in like a knee bet position. Yeah. I try to actually bias it towards my hamstring and glutes. When I do bungeists, I'm trying to do the mechanics so that I'm feeling it more my glutes and hamstrings compared to my quads. Like obviously you're going to get a lot of quads, but I know when the burpees come up and when the wall balls come.

17:54 my quads are going to get blasted. And the way Hyrox has done, dude, they are diabolical. Like the way, if you ever see the progression of the stations and the runs, it's meant to just add on to one another. So it's all about managing fatigue in the end and not necessarily actually being good at the exercise. So for me, knowing that when I do deadlifts or when I do heavy runs and legs, my back really tightens up, whether it's kind of the erectors or even the QL, even sometimes my psoas, like I'll start feeling just because again, it's just been tight. My hip flexors always been tight just with sprinting my whole life. So yeah, I mean, I think I like, I definitely think about those things, but what's interesting after high rocks, I'm not sure if I'm ever going to do it again. We'll see just because I don't, I'm not a big fan of how.

18:36 It's a running competition with then just a very leg dominant type of stations versus if you look at the lifetime games, which I think you did, that's more like pure strength where you're doing overhead presses, deadlifts, things like that. It's more global with less running. So I think it's less taxing overall and more athletic in my opinion. So like I'm excited to be done with high rock. So that way I can train for that or that type of training at least where that I can definitely get back to deadlifts, get back to training the hamstrings and just feel more swole overall if that makes sense. Yeah, a little bit more resistance training bias as opposed to more of a running cardiovascular bias. Yeah, again, pros and cons, you just have to pick which master you're choosing. And so the other interesting thing I think was worth noting is on the flip side, we'll argue that why it's not that such a big deal, right?

19:20 And so I was looking at, okay, well, what's this idea of minimum effective dose? I think that in medicine, we understand, right, minimum effective dose. There's the maximum tolerable dose. So MED, MTD is the things that we look at when we talk about medicines. I think that from Renaissance precision, I think he had talked about maximum recoverable volume is, I think that's a term that he's coined or I'm not sure if he's coined, but I've heard him talk a lot about, and then what's the minimum viable volume. So I think you're talking about the same thing, but I like using the dose term because I do think exercise is medicine. And so it's like, okay, well, what's the ideal therapeutic dose that we're looking at? For the purposes of being a comprehensive program, if training for the sake of training is your gold, then yeah, both you and I are not going to be meeting it. That being said, you just highlighted, okay, listen, I got to get through this.

20:03 And right now I'm making these shred offs very intentionally. And then we'll look at the next thing. And depending on what we're doing periodization wise, then we'll change it up. Here's the good news, right? So while looking for this and looking, well, what's the minimum effective dose to me to preserve that muscle size? And it came across this 2021 paper. Sparing and colleagues that they looked at where they looked at younger adults. I don't think this is anymore, unfortunately, buddy. But what they talked about is one session a week and one set per exercise can maintain strength and size for up to 32 weeks. Right. So that's pretty awesome. I think these people were in their like mid 20s. So as long as the load stays heavy and it's relative to your max. Now, the downside is that's not what you're doing. Right. You're going towards that more endurance based thing that you're talking about. But even in older adults, keeping size might take up to two sessions and two to three sets.

20:48 So it's not really that much more volume that we have to be able to hit. And so when we're looking at your program here, upper body is probably doing its job. Lower body is doing its job. I'm curious with the quad stuff, if you're pushing lunges to such high volume, you're probably not getting that 80% one RM that we talked about. That's okay. Like you just talked about with lifestyle games. And so, yeah, I'm curious to see how Things are going to change and where we're going to be. Maybe we revisit this in about six weeks after your performance. As long as you haven't made a fool of yourself, all over social media, and you don't have to hide under a rock for a while. True. So my program right now, I'm doing three full body training days and I have one really intense, I guess we can call it a zone five interval, sprint interval training on a airline bike.

21:36 And so when I'm doing calculations on my own thing, I'll have, I'm almost always doing some type of push variation or horizontal push. I don't do a vertical push right now because I am still recovering from shoulder surgery. It's typically biased towards a horizontal pull and a vertical pull and shoulders are going to be coming into my push and then biceps and stuff. Again, I'm not doing any isolation based. The only isolation based stuff that I'm doing is going to be for lower body. That's going to be in either leg extension, leg curls, calves, or triceps, biceps. It's going to be more back-based stuff. And so for me, one of those movements every single day, and some days it's going to be more than one. Some movements are going to catch. And so when we go back to that rule that I talked about from those Peller colleagues with the one set primary and half set, I come out to about six to eight.

22:23 six to eight sets for chest, six to eight for back, six to eight for shoulder, three to four for biceps, five to seven for triceps, a little bit more quad heavy, 10 to 12, excluding my air nine, glutes from six, six and a half to seven and a half and hamstring is six. So, and calves is about, I'm doing this hypertrophy cluster set that I learned from Dan Garner, big fan. I'll tell you about it later, or if you're interested, we can talk about it here. But so, so that brings six sets in there. So it's pretty even, but the volume, as you'll notice, pretty low. I mentioned earlier, there are a bunch of other constraints in life with respect to work, with respect to being a parent, with respect to other musculoskeletal injuries. And so all these things really do play a role. But I think that it matters. And I guess I had brought up the term allostatic load.

23:06 And I had mentioned that I think that this is something that people don't give enough weight to when they're thinking about their programming, because we think all about the external load. Most of this conversation is based on that. But what is your understanding of the term allostatic load and how do you program for that? Honestly, I don't think I could give you a good answer. All I know, aloe meaning self, static meaning using your own weight. So if this is more like calisthenics, push-ups, things like that, then that would be my understanding. Yeah, totally wrong. Totally wrong. Yeah, nice. Okay. That Latin didn't do me any good. Sure. I love you. No. So, yeah. So I think the concept was invented by these two folks.

23:47 I forget. McGowan or something else. I can't remember the second pair. But anyways, what it's talking about is. It's been stellar. Thank you. McGowan is stellar. And in the 1930s or 40s. Oh, I'm so wrong. I love it. It's okay. This is great. And really what we're talking about is all these other stressors, right? So we have talked about, and when people are coming to us with pain, right, this concept of biopsychosocial model of pain, right? We have to look at not just the biological constructs that are contributing to some type of physiological changes and adaptation, but also what's the psychology look like and what are the other social factors that we have to consider? Well, when it comes to training, all that stuff matters. So we've talked about this before that your body doesn't do a good job differentiating between the types of stress, right?

24:33 Yes, there's eustress, there's distress. And technically exercise is a type of distress. And over time, as long as you don't exceed your maximum tolerable dose and capacity to recover, you will adapt and you will be more resilient. However, if you are sleeping really poorly because you're in residency or you have a newborn at home or your parent is sick or your child is sick and you're spending nights at the hospital, well, that's taking a lot of stress, right? So those are psychosocial stressors that you have. Sleep quality or nutrition or whatever you have, things outside of the gym affect your physiology. pretty significantly that it's going to not only affect your performance, but it's going to affect your capacity or your capability of recovering.

25:14 And if you're not recovering, well, the likelihood that you're going to get injured, you're not going to perform. You talked about central nervous system fatigue earlier. Well, yeah, if your central nervous system is fried, you're not going to be able to produce force. You're not going to train hard. And so all those things really need to be accounted for. So I've alluded to this in episode one, episode two here. I'm going to talk about this again, because this is where people don't pay enough attention to. This is actually where external accountability and coaching is really helpful, because especially you, I'm not going to gloss over the fact that he's like, yeah, I tend to just push through things despite... Being somebody who is so into the weeds, so self-attuned and has deep interest and knowledge and desire to pursue this, like it's this is what we like to do.

25:59 Right. And so this is the gamification. What's not so fun, despite all the wearables making it fun, your readiness score, all that kind of stuff is to put a lot of weight into that, not even touch on like the accuracy of those things. But actually, I guess maybe it is worth it. So you told the listener last time that you were looking at the Luna Band. You now have the Luna Band. Tell me, now that you understand what allostatic load is, how has Luna Band helped you account for the variables outside the gym that's affected your high rocks training and modification? Yeah, it's funny you bring this up because that is exactly what the LudaBan has done differently for me compared to when I had the Wub or anything else. I think it really does shine on the allostatic load piece of it.

26:41 So when you look at the LudaBan, there's three kind of components to it. One is the sleep. The other is the activity that they'll monitor. The other is the recovery. I don't think I ever paid much attention to the recovery as much as I had previously. Like the recovery aspect of my training has always just been mental or it's always been just something that I tried to look at. When I look at the Luda band, it looks at the suggestions it's giving me. Like yesterday, it was like, do 15 minutes of pre-sleep breathing. Do a 10-minute mobility session. So it's actively engaging me into these types of activities that, sure, I would do, but I never really thought of. So now when I've come to high rock training, because again, I mentioned how my back will tighten up or... whatever it might be.

27:22 If it's telling, if my workout program and AI saying, Hey, I want you to run at seven miles per hour for these four miles. And I started feeling my back, the Luna band or whatever, now that I have that insight, I'll be like, you know what, let me drop it down to 6.8 or 6.7 and save my back. So that way I can train tomorrow, you know, and still hit that same type of capacity that I'm hitting today. So I think that's where it has made a difference that I'm not seeing in terms of like other wearables again i haven't used whoop in two three years i think it has done a better job now but yeah i do think it's interesting that eight sleep these things have at least helped me understand hey you're not losing the day just because you have low hrb or anything go push but just be smart about it yeah do you find that I'm curious because one of the problems with that is where the band might say, hey, listen, turn it down, turn the dial down a little bit when you actually shouldn't be turning the dial down.

28:16 And you find that your internal queuing system is telling you, hey, I want to turn the dial down and the Luna band is saying, is that concordant or? So again, my personality wise, I'll always push to like what I feel like I can do and always strive for more. And then I've had pretty good kinesthetic intelligence where I feel like, okay, I'm My quads are starting to tighten or this is starting to happen. If I keep going, I'm going to compromise something. Let me now dial it back a little bit. So I feel doing this my whole life. I do have a good understanding of what my body can push through and handle and what I have upcoming in the next days. I've just been smarter about it. And I just realized, okay, I'm 34 now. Like that, it does make a difference. And like I always feel, because I have the heart of a 20-year-old and I'm like that, but that age doesn't mess around.

29:00 So, yeah. Yeah, biology is undefeated, right? And that's good. That's good because I think it's going to help you preserve from a longevity perspective so you can maybe keep doing paradox in 20 years if it's still around. We'll see. So anything that you think that we've left out? If not, I'll just touch on some quick fire things that maybe we'll have questions about. Hyperotophy and strength perspective. Sure. Question for you. So you mentioned how you do full body training. So this might be a series of questions. So I think if you look at 10, 15 years ago, maybe even five push pull legs was always like that. Holy grail. I feel when some of you were starting out and maybe it still is. But now you look at like Andrew Huberman. Right. And he talked about how he does full body.

29:40 And I feel like a lot of people tend to follow what he does now since he has a book out on protocols and whatnot. So when you're looking at allostatic load from doing a full body perspective, how do you prevent soreness? Or how do you think about when you're doing those three days? I'm assuming you're not doing them back to back unless, you know, your week calls for it. But tell me a little bit about why you're doing the full body and then how you spread that out or how you think about programming it throughout the week. Sure. Let me take the... Second question first, why I do full body. I think from an efficiency perspective, full body allows me to be able to go if I want to superset and not have any competing sets or competing exercises that allows me to do that, right? So for instance, if I want to superset an upper body movement with a lower body movement, as long as there is a heavy grip intensive thing, like for instance, if I'm doing a back exercise with a deadlift, that's going to be a problem because the fatiguing thing is going to be my grip, right?

30:32 But if I'm doing a back exercise with a squat variation or a leg extension movement, I can superset and really not have any type of compromise between the training thing. Even with upper body, like a push pull, like you had pointed about, if somebody is doing an upper body superset, your shoulders are still pretty involved. Right. So they're getting beat up, especially if you have some orthopedic constraints like I do. Yeah. So with upper and lower supersetting variation, it doesn't happen. Now that also allows me to push harder and keep my heart rate a little higher. That's how I like to move in the gym, right? So from that perspective, it's my work. It can be a little bit faster. The other thing is right now I have a limited amount of time of how much I can spend with actual dedicated workout just because of the things going on outside of the gym.

31:16 And so it's like, okay, well, I know that because I'm doing more rehab oriented stuff in the beginning, both for lower body hip issue and shoulder issue. Earlier on, when you're still rehabbing, tissues respond better to frequency. And so getting in three times a week, full body workout, as opposed to what my preferred method is to do an upper lower split four days of resistance training, right? I would, that those tissues will only see potentially the gym twice a week. Whereas now I can have those tissues see the gym three times a week. Does that make sense? So the frequency is like more important to me right now and to be able to get like a full body workout. Like ideally, when I probably go on later, when I go and leave later this year, I will probably go to like a full, excuse me, an upper lower split.

32:01 And I'll probably have an extra two days of built in cardiorespiratory training. So I'm going to be like training six days a week. That's kind of like my preferred way to do it. But right now I can only dedicate three and a half, four days. That makes more sense. To your first question, I would have actually a follow-up question. It's like, why am I trying to prevent soreness? You mentioned how do I prevent soreness? I guess not soreness. I guess what I mean is being fully recovered, getting into kind of that next workout. From push to pull? Yeah, from push to pull. Or like if you know you're going to have shoulders with your pull or with your push, right? Let's say they are sore and maybe not fully recovered where you can't. hit whatever goal it is that you want let's say with that pull the next day or the next two days that like what i'm yeah what i mean i'm just trying to think from the audience perspective they're like well i get beat up like how am i going to do another full body i got you yeah i wonder if we're thinking the same thing so traditionally the push pull split that i'm thinking of is you'll do all types of pushing based movements which for lower body would be your squats and lunges and upper body pushing would be Upper body pushing would be pressing variations.

33:02 And then the next day, so if you did that Monday, Tuesday would be all your pulling variations would be all kind of deadlifts and back type stuff. So that's your upper and lower pull. And that's how people look at it. So that's one push pull, right? And that you can look at. So that's one variation. Other people have a push pull upper body, just only upper body push, upper body pull, and then a full leg thing. Now, if you're doing the upper body push back to back and you're splitting the legs, I would probably structure it such so. depending on how many days a week you want to train, right? This is where we had talked about in episode one. It's like, how much time do you actually have? Let's say you're telling me you have three, three and a half weeks. I would say, okay, well, Monday you do upper body push. Tuesday, your upper body pull. I would take Wednesday off, either Thursday or Friday, I would do a full.

33:45 Again, that gives you enough time that you train hard enough that the nervous system has recovered. So yes, you're going to have some soreness in the muscles from Monday to Tuesday. It also depends on like... when DOMS onset is for you. The literature will say DOMS onset could be anywhere from six hours to 24 hours, but some people will be on the shorter engine. Some people don't get DOMS until 30 hours after. So it really depends. Even if you do get DOMS, right, so this delayed onset muscle stonars for those who don't know, Well, that is going to be on the push day will typically be in your anterior delts and your triceps and your chest. When you're doing the pressing, excuse me, pulling movements the next day, that really shouldn't have much of an effect.

34:28 Right. Now, if your rotator cuff is irritated, it's not going to discriminate between the push and pull depending on the type of movement. Again, there's more to this than we can talk about in like a 35 minute episode. We're already much more into that. But I think that typically there's not much of an overlap and that's probably okay. Yeah. Again, trust your user experience. There is a phase that you have to adapt and your tissues have to acclimate. So if you're a beginner going into that, shit, you're going to be sort of what you do. So I think you have to figure out what works for you. Does that answer your question? Yeah, that absolutely makes sense. What would you say, Alice, that's independent, the type of program you would do? Yeah, I think when I'm thinking about allostatic load, you're looking at the big picture, right?

35:10 Typically, again, I wanted to make about, so the way that I actually teach people this is there's external load, then internal load. So external load is everything that we've just talked about, right? Weights and loads and reps and that kind of stuff. Internal load is a thing that are non-quantifiable factors that actually your lunar band is telling you about. Dude, you didn't sleep well. Your HRV is off because you've been breathing like really shallow because something is happening because you're stressed out. Like, I think that's why it's like, what's your internal load? What's your super centurial state that is affecting that? And so that's how I try to define that. I think I did a post on this a while back about people just don't consider that. So allostatic load is just kind of the umbrella thing where people are only looking at external load. Cool.

35:50 What else? Do you have anything else for me? Yeah, that's it, I think. Yeah. Awesome. Well, I think that the other thing that probably worth mentioning, I give this a little shout is like with respect to machine weights, a machine versus free weights, really no consistent difference when you look at the literature for size or for strength. There's not enough data to call it. So pick whatever lets you progress safely, that overload that we talked about and keep showing up. As far as rest, we go back and forth between that. Earlier, when you look at the essential strength and conditioning guidelines that you had talked about, that range that the graph people look at, for the longest time, they would say, look, somewhere between 30 to 90 seconds is for hypertrophy. For strength, it could be anywhere from two to five minutes. Again, it turns out this recent 2024 meta-analysis that I was looking at with Singer and colleagues, there's maybe a small edge for resting longer than a minute, but really no clear added benefit past 90 seconds.

36:40 So again, whatever your variation is. So coming back to my program, if I'm going from one exercise to the next, if I'm going to leg extensions, by the time I'm done that and I go do, let's say a set of 15 reps or a set of 10 reps heavy on my back exercise, well, that's probably taken me 45 seconds to 60 seconds. That's my time. I can either dive right into it or I can take 15 seconds, catch my breath, which will pull me right around the 90 second mark. And I can do that, right? If I feel a little bit more spent because I haven't slept well or whatever, I'm not feeling great. If I'm training later in the day, I don't like training in the evening and I just move a little bit slower. I might take a little bit longer. I like... Something I heard Andy Galpin talk about is his philosophy has evolved on this.

37:21 And now he'll tell his athletes, just take as little or as long as you need to make sure that quality is preserved set to set. I think as I get a little bit older, I'm starting to shift a little bit more to that. Do you get a little stressed out about your... I used to time it back in the day. Oh man, I got to run. Yeah, yeah. I used to be a little OCD about it. Yeah, no, I think I heard the same thing from Andy Galpin and that what I do now is really just, I look at my breathing and I just say, am I ready to put a quality set in? And I've just been using this badly. Yeah. As far as longevity, which is the sexiest word of all, there was this 2026 paper I think we had posted about it. I think Clay Moss actually talked about this as well, where Zhang and colleagues looked at the lowest mortality estimate for strength training was anywhere between 90 to 119 minutes of resistance training a week with really no added mortality benefit above 120.

38:12 So it's actually pretty low bar, right? And so again, the lowest risk is for people doing both lifting and aerobic work. So which one's more important? It's again, both of them with the largest gap being going from nothing to something. And again, these big studies, when you're hearing these numbers, these are going to be observational studies. And so you have to keep that in mind, but we'll talk a little bit about the second half of I think one thing, again, I'll say is maybe one of the most important concepts is understanding aesthetic load, but also understanding constraints. You and I talked offline about the importance of constraints, is setting those constraints and how they become your clarity. They allow you to build where that floor is, and then you think about adding bonus. Historically, what I used to do was think about, okay, what's somebody's ideal workout?

38:56 We even talked about this, like, okay, build an ideal workout, and then maybe think about what the backup plan would look like. I'm actually starting to think that maybe actually build the floor first, right? Think about what's the minimum effect of it. It's like, what's your backup week look like when you can't do stuff, when you know you're going to be traveling, when you know you're going to be pressed for time. So if I'm talking to you and you're like, I'm training for high rocks, I'm like, okay, well, imagine you're doing high rocks and you got the presentation, you got the thing that's going on, you got the meetings. What's that week training look like? When we nail that, then we might start adding and look at that as bonus. From a coaching psychological perspective, this is better because I think for high performers such as yourself and... For myself, I think that over time, as life starts to build in and take over, cutting feels really uncomfortable to take things away.

39:44 When you're like, I can't do this, I can't do this. It's like the things that you pointed. So what maybe works a little bit better is like adding in is always nice. Oh yeah, you're doing good. Here's a bonus. Go do another exercise. Go do another exercise. That's good. So I think that's actually something that's been really helpful is like identify, hey, what's your best program and what are your actual constraints? Let's program around your constraints and then add in where we have extra. Oh, you've been sleeping really weak. Oh, you got a high recovery score and you feel good. Life is happy. Let's go for that extra half a mile or let's do an extra thing. So that's something that I've actually shifted over the last maybe five to 10 years as I'm communicating with patients as well. I love that, man. I think James Clear, I'm trying to look for his newsletter right now. He wrote something similar to this about how when building a habit, plan it around your worst week, because that's going to be the lowest bar that you can at least build upon versus looking at the ideal day.

40:33 So exactly what you're talking about right now. Good. I love that. I'm in good company then. Awesome. All right, man. I think that probably wraps this up a little bit longer. And yeah, we'll come back next week for cardio stuff. Sounds good. Awesome. Thanks for listening to another episode of Medicine Redefined. If you enjoyed this episode, please be sure to check out some of the additional resources in the show notes. Please also check out our social media platforms where you can find more content like this. You can follow us on Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok at medredefined. We also want to thank our team for the production of this podcast, specifically Ethan Ju on video, Harita Yekori on social media, Zanab Lugmani on research, and Saira Khan for newsletter. Oh, and if you want to get similar bite-sized information delivered to your inbox every Sunday, please be sure to sign up for our newsletter.

41:20 Also, if you enjoy the show, please be sure to subscribe, review, and share with anyone who you think will gain value from this as well. Now, time for the ever-so-important disclaimers. This podcast is intended for general public use and is for educational purposes only. It does not constitute the practice of medicine, nor should be construed as medical advice. No physician-patient relationship is formed, and anything discussed in this podcast does not represent the views of our employers. We recommend that you seek the guidance of your personal physician regarding any specific health-related issues.